While we’ll definitely comb through reviews when shopping for new clothes, nothing beats a recommendation from a trusted friend and fellow editor. After all, we spend hours a day being tempted by dresses, leggings, jumpsuits, and more so, when we finally click to purchase, we’re more than happy to share with everyone in earshot.

Take a white tee that holds up so well through multiple wears and washes that it’s quite possibly woven with magic? Let’s abracadabra that right into our own cart. Or, how about a tie-dye workout set that looks like it costs at least three times its actual price? We’re ready to be twins. See these Old Navy items ahead (along with more editor-approved finds), and we’re including our actual reviews and photos, too.